Clinging to a dangerous past: Dr Paul McHugh’s selective reading of transgender medical literature
In a June 12th opinion article in the Wall Street Journal, well-known anti-transgender psychiatrist Dr. Paul McHugh attempts to make a case against supporting hormonal and surgical transition for transgender individuals. McHugh, professor of psychiatry at Johns Hopkins University, has been actively working against the medical treatment of trans people since the 1970’s. As the university’s chief psychiatrist, he was instrumental in closing the Johns Hopkins Gender Program in 1979, one of the first programs of its kind, citing the 1977 study by his Hopkins colleague Dr. Jon Meyer, which claimed that surgical intervention did not improve the psychological functioning of the individuals treated. McHugh himself admits to directing Meyer to conduct to further his anti-trans agenda in a 2004 article titled “Surgical Sex”. In the same article, McHugh also continues to preach the largely discredited “autogynephilia” theory of Ray Blanchard and J. Michael Bailey. McHugh is also known for
The Source Summary reproduces the first 150 words of the source article unless a Collective editor has explicitly locked a replacement.
Why this article may matter
Community significance
“Clinging to a dangerous past: Dr Paul McHugh’s selective reading of transgender medical literature” may matter to community readers because it preserves a first-person or testimonial account connected to transgender identity and history, while also engaging healthcare and medicine. Such accounts can document how an issue was understood and experienced from within the period or community being discussed.
Historical significance
The article may have historical value because it explicitly interprets or preserves material concerning transgender identity and history. Published in 2014 by Transadvocate.com, it can be read both for the history it describes and as evidence of how healthcare and medicine was framed at that moment.
Policy significance
The article’s strongest policy connection is criminal justice and public safety and healthcare regulation. It links that institutional frame to transgender identity and history and healthcare and medicine, making it potentially useful for tracing how an argument moves from description or history into law, regulation, administration, or public practice.
Ranked themes and framings
Rank 1 is the dominant inferred theme or framing. Parent labels identify broader theme families; the relationship key beneath the diagram explains the line styles used for hierarchy, same-family relationships, overlap, and separate-but-related themes.
Themes
- 1Transgender identity and historyTheme family: Identity, culture, and community100%
- 2Healthcare and medicineTheme family: Institutions, law, and public life63%
- 3Science, evidence, and expertiseTheme family: Knowledge, history, and communication53%
- 4Education and youthTheme family: Institutions, law, and public life26%
- 5Law and civil rightsTheme family: Institutions, law, and public life24%
- 6Violence, safety, and dehumanizationTheme family: Power, ideology, and social conflict16%
Academic framing
- 1100%
- 258%
- 310%
- 48%
Policy framing
- 1100%
- 225%
- 325%
Editorial function
Source topics
- Overlapping themes
- Separate but related themes
These classifications are inferred from article text and source metadata and remain directly editable. Relationship labels express corpus-analysis judgments, not immutable facts.
How “Transgender identity and history” appears across the Collective corpus
This article appeared 1 year(s) after the theme’s highest annual presence in the registered corpus in 2013.
Relative presence by year
Peak year indexed to 100Presence by member publication
Frequently co-occurring concepts
- Community and organizing531
- Law and civil rights468
- Culture, identity, and representation320
- Education and youth308
- Media, rhetoric, and discourse260
- Healthcare and medicine248
- Violence, safety, and dehumanization238
- History, archives, and memory216
- Public policy and governance206
- Feminism and gender politics198
Academic framings in this topic
Policy framings in this topic
- Public accommodations and facilities177
- Civil rights and anti-discrimination173
- Criminal justice and public safety131
- Elections and democratic governance100
- Research ethics and data governance78
- Labor and employment policy52
- Administrative classification and identity documents39
- Housing and social services38
Values measure relative presence in the registered Collective corpus, not public search interest or public opinion.
Documented circulation and reception
56 source-held references record early links or citations; the documented sources span 42 distinct domains. The dated evidence currently spans 2014–2017. These observations describe circulation and reuse; they do not assign cultural worth or evaluate the communities, arguments, or people discussed.
Evidence by channel
Independent counts; bars are not additiveCoverage of the evidence search
Shows what has actually been checkedDocumented references over time
Dated source evidence currently stored by the CollectiveFact check: study shows transition makes trans people suicidal | The TransAdvocate
McHugh’s fact assertions were uncritically repeated by The American Conservative, Lifesite, The Christian Post, The Washington Times, Newsmax, One News Now, The Libertarian Republic, and Fox News. While McHugh’s misrepresentation of the study was debunked, the “trans medical care = suicide” meme was born. Since…
Rhetoric | Gemini, Trans
Clinging to a dangerous past: Dr Paul McHugh’s selective reading of transgender medical literature
Mari Brighe
Clinging to a dangerous past: Dr Paul McHugh’s selective reading of transgender medical literature
Why Straight Men Kill The Trans Women They Love - Page 13
[…] […]
Combaterea considerentelor anti-transgender – Transgender Magazine
[…] nu este mai mult decât un element marginal disconsiderat în propriul domeniu, puteți citi asta aici, aici, aici, aici, aici și aici. Nicio organizație medicală seculară sau organizație pentru […]
New Atlantis Study On Alternate Sexualities Says People Aren't Born Gay
[…] peppered his career over the last quarter of a century. Houston-based non-profit TransAdvocate has documented (among other things) his problematic linking of trans identities with mental illness, and let’s […]
The Christian Right’s Love Affair with Anti-Trans Feminists | Political Research Associates
[…] the American Psychological Association, and the American Psychiatric Society, the two dredged up obscure and outdated scientific theories in an attempt to pathologize transgender people (thereby justifying their […]
Transgender Surgery | America's Bad Side
[…] Related: Surgical Sex […]
Should we treat transgenders as mentally ill? - Page 50 - Defending The Truth Political Forum
[…] The TransAdvocate | Clinging to a dangerous past: Dr Paul McHugh?s selective reading of transgender … i cannot remember how often i have said you dont understand how science operates. there are varying opinions in medicine, every field. so far i have presented the…
Geena Amandus
The Mask of Compassion: How LovinglyTo Mess Up a Life I Posted on December 5, 2015 by Geena Amandus — Leave a comment Disclaimer: Trigger Alert. If you are thinking you are transgender, and thinking about transitioning, or if you are transitioning, or you are…
[…] […]
[…] […]
richie.terry@theseattleschool.edu
Matt Walsh wrote an article today entitled “Parents, Teach Your Kids To Be Virtuous. The Schools Can’t Do It For You.” Sounds innocuous enough, and maybe, in some alternate universe, it would provide some helpful advice to parents on loving their kids and helping them…
Show 45 additional documented sources
Wow, it sure is easy to become a “psychology expert” on Fox News - Atheist Boutique
By PZ Myers They have one! Her name is Gina Loudon, and her qualifications are… Loudon, a tea party activist who became a reality star after she and her husband joined ABC’s Wife Swap She also has a Ph.D. in a “psychology related field” from…
What do the statistics say about transgender mental health? | The Lighthouse - Minnesota Catholic Conference - Minnesota Politics and Public Policy - Catholic…
Marriage and Family Previous What do the statistics say about transgender mental health? (Originally seen on Conjugality: A Blog on the Future of Marriage) By Michael Cook October 23, 2015 In the sudden avalanche of publicity for transgender issues since Bruce Jenner announced that he…
Neal Schindler
Winning and losing moves in the battle against transphobia
Cristan
Views: 147A couple of days ago I wrote about my feelings of disgust regarding the behavior of some Tumblr TERFs. While I was responding to an older Tumbr TERF post, they continued to fire back at trans people on Tumblr who were citing my work. TERFs Fire…
If You Can Be Transgender, Why Can’t You Be Transracial? | NUHISON
[…] the words of Dr. Paul McHugh, one of the nation’s most respected psychiatrists yet a man despised by many in the transgender community as out of date and out of touch, “Transgendered men do […]
Fighting Back against Anti-Transgender Talking Points | Brynn Tannehill
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here,here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with him. […]
Why We Need to Address Transgender Issues | Brynn Tannehill
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here,here, and […]
"Call me Caitlyn" Jenner - Page 3
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with […]
A Quick Note On The Statistics Of “Post-Surgery Trans Regret” | Rani Bakr Digs You.
[…] Paul McHugh is a fucking hack and you should be ashamed of yourself to quote him. He was also an ideological accomplice to […]
NBC Series on Transgender Children - Page 4 - Christian Forums
[…] with accepting the reality of the scientific perspective on the issues of transgender treatment. This is a breakdown of some issues with how Dr. McHugh handles information on trans care. that studies show between […]
The Absurdity Of Rejecting Transgender Identities: A Response To Widely-Circulated Harmful Bigotry | ZackFord Blogs
[…] matter that McHugh’s interpretation of the research on transgender people has been thoroughly debunked. It doesn’t matter that McHugh’s biases against all LGBT people, rejecting decades of […]
Religious Right, Catholic Church continue fight against trans-inclusive athletics policy | The Column
[…] Contrary to MNCPL’s claim, only one study indicated “that 70%-80% of children with transgender feelings spontaneously lose those feelings by the time they are adults” — not multiple studies as MNCPL’s language suggests. MNCPL’s email takes language that comes from Dr. Paul McHugh, a…
Why We Need to Address Transgender Issues -
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here,here, and […]
Fighting Back Against Anti-Transgender Talking Points -
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here,here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with him. […]
Feminist Issues Are Transgender Issues | Political Ration
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and […]
Feminist Issues Are Transgender Issues | CauseHub
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and […]
Feminist Issues Are Transgender Issues | Brynn Tannehill
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and […]
Feminist Issues Are Transgender Issues | Omaha Sun Times
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and […]
Feminist Issues Are Transgender Issues | Pride & Equality Post
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and […]
Feminist Issues Are Transgender Issues,PrideNation Magazine
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and […]
Feminist Issues Are Transgender Issues | So Stadium Status
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and […]
Feminist Issues Are Transgender Issues Posted on October 15, 2014 by .ss1_wrapper a.slideshow_prev .color-transparent, .ss1_wrapper a.slideshow_prev:hover .color-transparent, .ss1_wrapper a.slideshow_next .color-transparent, .ss1_wrapper a.slideshow_next:hover .color-transparent, .ss1_wrapper…
Feminist Issues Are Transgender Issues Posted on October 15, 2014 by .ss1_wrapper a.slideshow_prev .color-transparent, .ss1_wrapper a.slideshow_prev:hover .color-transparent, .ss1_wrapper a.slideshow_next .color-transparent, .ss1_wrapper a.slideshow_next:hover .color-transparent, .ss1_wrapper .slideshow_paging a .color-transparent, .ss1_wrapper .slideshow_box .data .color-transparent { background: #000000; } .ss1_wrapper .slideshow_paging a.activeSlide, .ss1_wrapper .slideshow_paging a:hover.activeSlide { color: #000000; }…
TERF Wars: Trans Women and Feminist Extremism in Context | LUYOL
[…] the change in cultural authority led to the shutdown of the Hopkins program by the infamous Professor Paul McHugh. That conservative backlash infected the feminist community as well, generating a second wave of […]
TERF Wars: Trans Women and Feminist Extremism in Context | Safe Schools | Desert Cities
[…] the change in cultural authority led to the shutdown of the Hopkins program by the infamous Professor Paul McHugh. That conservative backlash infected the feminist community as well, generating a second wave of […]
TERF Wars: Trans Women and Feminist Extremism in Context | Livin'it Good
[…] the change in cultural authority led to the shutdown of the Hopkins program by the infamous Professor Paul McHugh. That conservative backlash infected the feminist community as well, generating a second wave of […]
TERF Wars: Trans Women and Feminist Extremism in Context | Triple X News
[…] the change in cultural authority led to the shutdown of the Hopkins program by the infamous Professor Paul McHugh. That conservative backlash infected the feminist community as well, generating a second wave of […]
TERF Wars: Trans Women and Feminist Extremism in Context | Pride & Equality Post
[…] the change in cultural authority led to the shutdown of the Hopkins program by the infamous Professor Paul McHugh. That conservative backlash infected the feminist community as well, generating a second wave of […]
TERF Wars: Trans Women and Feminist Extremism in Context | LGBTCentral - Your Source for LGBT news
[…] the change in cultural authority led to the shutdown of the Hopkins program by the infamous Professor Paul McHugh. That conservative backlash infected the feminist community as well, generating a second wave of […]
TERF Wars: Trans Women and Feminist Extremism in Context | CauseHub
[…] the change in cultural authority led to the shutdown of the Hopkins program by the infamous Professor Paul McHugh. That conservative backlash infected the feminist community as well, generating a second wave of […]
Fighting Back Against Anti-Transgender Talking Points | Triple X News
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with […]
Fighting Back Against Anti-Transgender Talking Points | Safe Schools | Desert Cities
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with […]
Fighting Back Against Anti-Transgender Talking Points,PrideNation Magazine
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with […]
Fighting Back Against Anti-Transgender Talking Points | Gay Denver and All of Gay Colorado
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here , here , here , here , here , and here . No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees […]
Fighting Back Against Anti-Transgender Talking Points | CauseHub
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with […]
전세계의 최신 영어뉴스 듣기 - 보이스뉴스 잉글리쉬
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with […]
Fighting Back Against Anti-Transgender Talking Points | NEWS | Phones | Nigeria Science | Technology |Computers
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with […]
Fighting Back Against Anti-Transgender Talking Points | LGBTCentral - Your Source for LGBT news
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with […]
Fighting Back Against Anti-Transgender Talking Points | Pride & Equality Post
[…] and is nothing more than a poorly regarded fringe element in his own field, you can read about it here, here, here, here, here, and here. No secular medical or mental-health organization agrees with […]
Conservatives and the Transgender Time Warp Posted on July 25, 2014 by //<![CDATA[ reddit_url="http://www.brynntannehill.com/conservatives-and-the-transgender-time-warp/"; //]]> Since the TIME magazine cover story, “The Transgender Tipping…
Conservatives and the Transgender Time Warp Posted on July 25, 2014 by //<![CDATA[ reddit_url="http://www.brynntannehill.com/conservatives-and-the-transgender-time-warp/"; //]]> Since the TIME magazine cover story, “The Transgender Tipping Point,” there has been a distinct whiff of panic coming from social conservatives. The idea of transgender people, and their issues,…
The Myths and Big Lies Continue | Joys and desperation = life
[…] For more information on debunking this hoax, GO Here: […]
World’s experts condemn the McHugh hoax | The TransAdvocate
[…] See the full text of Mari’s response at http://www.transadvocate.com/clinging-to-a-dangerous-past-dr-paul-mchughs-selective-reading-of-trans… […]
Sex Change Regret | Alternative-News.tk
[…] This confirmed a similar study McHugh had commissioned decades earlier at Johns Hopkins, and for opposing sex-change surgery, he is vilified to this day. […]
Random Headlines — 6/19/14 | Bread and Roses
[…] The TransAdvocate – Dr. Paul McHugh’s “science” is transphobia in disguise. […]
The Wall Street Journal’s Ignorance on LGBTQ Issues Is Alarming | Honduprensa
[…] more effective to debunk his claims than to censor the op-ed. Genetics researcher Mari Brighe has done a great job of this over at TransAdvocate, so I’ll simply summarize her capable take-down: The single study McHugh cites for opposing […]
Lies, Damn Lies, and Lies About Transgender People Posted on June 16, 2014 by //<![CDATA[ reddit_url="http://www.brynntannehill.com/lies-damn-lies-and-lies-about-transgender-people/"; //]]> In the wake of Time magazine’s cover…
Lies, Damn Lies, and Lies About Transgender People Posted on June 16, 2014 by //<![CDATA[ reddit_url="http://www.brynntannehill.com/lies-damn-lies-and-lies-about-transgender-people/"; //]]> In the wake of Time magazine’s cover story about the “Transgender Tipping Point,” right-wing commentators have been out in force. This includes the National Review, the Wall Street…
Counts describe documented circulation and reception in the sources currently available to the Collective. They are not a score of quality, merit, popularity, or social value, and provider totals can overlap.
Author profiles and related researchers
Related authors in the Collective corpus
Cristan Williams
Shares registered themes including Transgender identity and history, Science, evidence, and expertise, Community and organizing.
Admin
Shares registered themes including Transgender identity and history, Science, evidence, and expertise, Community and organizing.
Cristan Williams
Shares registered themes including Transgender identity and history, Science, evidence, and expertise, Community and organizing.
Autumn Sandeen
Shares registered themes including Transgender identity and history, Science, evidence, and expertise, Community and organizing.
Gwen Smith
Shares registered themes including Transgender identity and history, Science, evidence, and expertise, Community and organizing.
Marti Abernathey
Shares registered themes including Transgender identity and history, Science, evidence, and expertise, Community and organizing.
Related authors are calculated from co-authorship, shared themes and framings, and citation relationships in the registered corpus. This does not imply a personal or institutional association.
Continue through the Collective
Trans Student Attacking Girls in School Restroom! Or, you know… not.
Examines legal, institutional, or policy consequences connected to the shared theme.
The push for radical transgender rights in schools is trumping privacy rights at one Colorado high school. A male student at Florence High School who claims to be…
Terf Quotes
Approaches the shared subject through a related analytical or disciplinary frame.
UPDATE: Aftermath of supposed cancellation of radfem2013 Bev Jo: They expect we’ll be shocked to see statistics about them being killed, and don’t realize, some of us wish…
1966: Intro to Transsexual Phenomena, Harry Benjamin
Provides a contextually related perspective from elsewhere in the Collective.
The TRANSSEXUAL PHENOMENON Harry Benjamin, M.D Preface and Acknowledgement There is a challenge as well as a handicap in writing a book on a subject that is not…
SBF: Children have rights Mr. Perkins
Approaches the shared subject through a related analytical or disciplinary frame.
The Slowly Boiled Frog is biting commentary from David Cary Hart reflecting upon issues affecting the LGBT community. Tony Perkins will argue vociferously that a fetus has rights.…